Fed monetary policy credibility caught between a rock and a hard place

Falling behind on inflation amid myriad intractable challenges

The Federal Reserve is rightly one of America’s most respected and revered institutions. Its leadership and staff are outstanding, and the Fed helped foster decades of price stability throughout the Great Moderation. Longer-term inflation expectations are broadly anchored.

Yet, the Great Moderation is yesterday’s story. Today’s monetary policy environment confronts difficult challenges. The track record in meeting those challenges, which are often well beyond the Fed’s control, is increasingly mixed. That redounds negatively on the Fed’s credibility and reputation.

Inflation

The Fed states that delivering price stability is its job. But the Fed’s inflation target has been missed for six years. While roughly steady inflation of around 3% still allows households and businesses to make reliable non-distortionary decisions, the target is 2% and the difference compounds over time. Further, Americans are increasingly inflation-sensitive, especially post-pandemic and given affordability concerns.

Amid low persisting inflation, the Fed developed its Flexible Average Inflation Targeting framework. The pandemic then hit, along with fiscal largesse and supply shocks. The framework soon was blamed for encouraging the Fed to continue too long with post-pandemic accommodation and took on the aura of mistakenly fighting the last war.

Inflation seems increasingly entrenched, given economic resilience, artificial intelligence demand, low unemployment, energy price hikes and tariffs. One can’t dismiss the possibility of a return to more moderate inflation near the target given a squeeze on real incomes and if, for example, oil prices fall and AI demand cools. Neither can one bank on that.

Monetary policy is best able to deal with demand shocks. The economy has been hit primarily by a series of supply shocks, many of which are beyond the Fed’s control. The Fed has been somewhat cautious, questioning whether the shocks are transitory and can be looked through. But demand seems increasingly buoyant and second-round effects are apparent. Financial conditions are arguably accommodative and not likely to be restrictive.

Many suggest the Fed is now behind the curve. Views vary between those who believe the Fed funds rate should move 50 basis points higher and those who are calling for 100bp. There is little doubt  that Doctor Fed must administer stronger medicine.

Communications

Clear and transparent Fed communication with markets is essential, especially as monetary policy works through the transmission of financial conditions to the real economy. That is not now happening. Chair Kevin Warsh is opposed to explicit forward guidance and believes the Fed should speak less and listen far more to market feedback, rather than vice versa.

Most agree that explicit forward guidance isn’t needed except at the zero lower bound. But they  also believe that, even if the Fed has been too explicit, it still should remain an important voice in shaping market expectations and that the market will seek out Fed views regardless, looking to the dot plot and Fed speeches.

Thus, they argue the Fed should clearly outline its reaction function. But Warsh’s press conferences are not seen as informative, meaning his views are not shaping market direction.

While Warsh’s relative silence – or interrogation of reality – may signify  he does not have to voice a hawkish stance that might upset super-dovish President Donald Trump, Fed communication is now seen as having deteriorated. This is a recipe for exacerbating uncertainty and volatility across the curve as global yields are on the ascent.

The White House and Treasury

Technical debates about the future of the Fed’s balance sheet, whether it strays into fiscal terrain and what it means for money market management rage on. But the bigger issue is what the obvious interconnections of fiscal and monetary policy signify for the Fed and its independence.

Trump has continued to plea for slashing the Fed funds rate, saving the government from a skyrocketing interest bill now in excess of 3% of gross domestic product and greater than annual US defence spending. He continues to minimise America’s inflation problem. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent – unusually – has publicly weighed in on Fed monetary policy, calling for lower rates and suggesting that higher energy prices should be looked through. In an unsuccessful effort to curb higher long-term rates, Bessent has upped the pace of Treasury buybacks.

Warsh has shown that he is a defender of the Fed’s monetary policy independence and disproven those who thought he could be Trump’s ’sock puppet’. But Warsh’s task forces are not dealing with the elephant in the room: America’s massive fiscal deficits. These deficits are helping sustain demand and inflation as well as pushing up longer-term yields. Beyond suggesting US fiscal policy is unsustainable, the Fed is gun-shy in speaking about the impact of fiscal policy for demand, inflation, the yield curve and monetary policy, perhaps so as not to perturb the president. But these topics are central to the Fed’s wheelhouse and America’s health. Are fiscal and financial dominance potential threats to America?

The Fed-Treasury relationship seems far less smooth than in the past, further compounding uncertainty.

The Fed is caught between a rock and a hard place. It is falling behind in coping with America’s current inflation challenges after missing its inflation target for six years. The challenges are generated largely by supply shocks – energy, wars, immigration crackdowns, AI, tariffs – over which the Fed has little control. But they now appear to be feeding demand. Communications have weakened, abetting volatility. A critical administration unwilling to tame its fiscal recklessness doesn’t help. Warsh’s Fed is increasingly behind the eight ball.

Mark Sobel is Vice Chair and Chief Economist of OMFIF.

Join OMFIF on 3 December for the next edition of the Chief economists briefing.

Interested in this topic? Subscribe to OMFIF’s newsletter for more.

Join Today

Connect with our membership team

Scroll to Top