[Skip to Content]

Register to receive the OMFIF Daily Update and trial the OMFIF membership dashboard for a month.

* Required Fields

Member Area Login

Forgotten Password?

Forgotten password

Analysis
Fairy-tale elements in German euro drama

Fairy-tale elements in German euro drama

‘No concessions’ says Merkel in mirror-image rebuke
The saga of the 243 and 192 professors

by David Marsh, OMFIF Chairman

Mon 16 Jul 2012

Germany’s contortions over monetary union contain strong elements of fairy-tale drama. Rebuking the now-enlarged group of 243 economists supporting Munich professor Hans-Werner Sinn’s attack on euro rescue plans, 192 professors have now signed a counter-petition backing the proposal for a Europe-wide banking union.

Chancellor Angela Merkel took to the TV screens on Sunday to deny that Germany had backed down at the end-June European summit to grant southern countries concessions over aid for their problem-hit economies. That’s just the opposite of what the Spanish and Italian leaders say. For centuries, such mirror-image depictions have been the stuff of popular north European mythology.

The various acts of the euro saga appear to have been taken directly from ‘The Sorcerer's Apprentice,’ ‘The Magic Porridge Pot’ and ‘The Emperor's New Clothes’: Goethe, the Brothers Grimm and Hans Christian Andersen have told the stories. They provide the script - even key characters - for the monetary union plot.

The sorcerer's apprentice, Jean-Claude Trichet, left to his devices at the peak of his fame, abuses the power of the old Bundesbank wizard. ‘Now his spirits shall obey my wishes! Having memorised what to say and do, with my powers of will I can do some witching too!’

Low German interest rates magically transform government bonds from inflationary southern Europe into prime-grade investment credits. The inexorable decline in capital market interest rates gives rise to a dangerous flood. The situation gets out of hand. Trichet cries out desperately: ‘Deliver me from the spirits that I called!’ The old sorcerer from the Bundesbank returns to the scene and commands the Greeks back into their corner: ‘Out with them’. And once again, on capital markets, calm reigns.

Greece and other southern countries already faced a precursor of future humiliation. As in the Brothers Grimm porridge pot story, the Greek people appear as ‘a poor, devout girl who lived alone with her mother, and she had nothing left to eat.’ With the euro comes conjured up a magic cooking pot. ‘The girl took the pot home, and they ate sweet porridge as often as they wanted.’ The more it is cooked, the lower the competitiveness, the higher the debts, but nobody knows how to stop the pot from boiling over.

‘So it went on cooking and the porridge rose over the edge and still it cooked, and soon kitchen and hearth and home and street and the whole wide world is flooded.’ Finally, the spell is broken with deflation and deleveraging. Revitalising the southern economies requires draining off a deep flood of debt: a long job of pain and sorrow.

And who uncovers the tale of woe? Step forward Hans-Olaf Henkel, former president of the Federation of German Industry, who was in London last week to formulate his views on the euro, and Hans-Werner Sinn of Germany’s IFO economics research institute. Both have kept up an indefatigable tide of realism on the currency union. Both have pointed to the hopelessness of the debt-deflation imbroglio, the insoluble riddles surrounding the European Central Bank’s Target 2 system. Both have been akin to the small boy in the ‘The Emperor’s New Clothes’ who divulge that, in fact, he’s not wearing any.

As a result of a combination of vanity, greed, inner self-doubt and desire to keep up appearances at the beginning of monetary union, no one mentioned at the outset that even wealthy Germany is not able to shoulder the debts of the others. All the people who were presented with the new euro garments by Empress Merkel extolled the exotic fabrics and the bright sequins of the new euro-gown. For many months she told her listeners that Germany would do everything possible to save the edifice. Only towards the end of the story does she admit Germany’s limitations: the old clothes are threadbare, new ones non-existent. The giant brought down to earth as a dwarf. We’ve been here before. As with the best fairy tales, one has a feeling it’s all going to end in tears.

Tell a friend View this page in PDF format